I got asked the other day why EPS feels so different. It's a great question, and part of the answer lives in the foam's density and how the board behaves at rest versus at speed. That's the thing most surfers don't fully unpack: buoyancy and lift are not the same. Understanding the difference changes how you read a board, and how you pick one.
Two states: at rest, and moving
When you look at a surfboard's relationship with water, it really exists in two states - resting, and moving. Sitting on the board between sets, you're being held up by static buoyancy. The moment you stand up and start gaining speed, something different takes over: dynamic lift. The board stops relying on its float and starts being held up by the way water moves underneath it.
Buoyant force

At rest, a surfboard floats thanks to buoyant force. Two things determine how easily it sinks or rises: volume and density. A heavier board with the same volume as a lighter one will be easier to sink.
Think PU versus EPS blank at identical dimensions - PU is denser, so it sits lower in the water at rest than EPS. That's why an EPS board often feels "corky" when you're sitting on it.
Dynamic lift
As soon as the board picks up speed, you're in a transition phase: the support shifts from buoyancy to lift. Once you're planing, the foam under your feet matters less, and the way water flows along the bottom contour matters more. That's lift.

The transition - the missing piece
Here's the part most riders don't think about: the transition from rest to planing is where construction makes itself known.
A denser PU board needs more speed before it transitions into lift mode, but once it gets there, it holds momentum easily and carries through sections with a stable, predictable feel. That's great for control at high speed.
A less dense EPS blank transitions into lift earlier - you feel it come alive sooner. But it also loses momentum more easily. That's why EPS can feel particularly sensitive to good waves, almost overactive in clean conditions, and why it tends to feel especially "alive" in small surf. It's lifting harder, and it shows.

Cheers
Hopefully that's useful. There are other factors that influence how a board feels - the glassing layup, resin type, fin setup - but I figured it was worth touching on this one for the surf nerds among you who like knowing why.
- Jake